Beaches & Cream Review: The Burgers Are Fine, but That’s Not Why You’re Here

We explore the savory menu in our Beaches and Cream review. The Disney’s Beach Club soda shop stays busy but we explain why the Kitchen Sink is the real reason to book it.

Beaches & Cream Soda Shop is one of the harder reservations to get on Walt Disney World property, and it has almost nothing to do with the food. That is not a knock; it is just the honest starting point for this Beaches and Cream review. The 1950s-style soda shop tucked into Disney’s Beach Club Resort has built a reputation that outruns its menu, and once you understand why, the whole place makes a lot more sense. This review covers the full savory menu, headlined by the Angus Beef Burger, before landing where the restaurant actually earns its keep: the ice cream.
Why This Reservation Is So Hard to Get

Beaches & Cream has always run small. Long before the 2019 refurbishment added seating by borrowing square footage from the neighboring arcade and Ariel’s, the restaurant seated guests at about ten tables plus a short counter, and reservations were capped at parties of four or fewer because there simply wasn’t room for anything bigger. Even after that expansion, the dining room’s capacity is still below 100 people. So, an advance dining reservation here is still a hard get. We have made the trip out to this corner of the Epcot resort area before, including a stop covered on our Episode 641 trip review, and the small footprint has been the story every single time.
This matters for how you should think about this restaurant. A dining room that seats well under 100 guests, sitting inside one of the most photographed pool complexes at Walt Disney World, is going to feel exclusive no matter what comes out of the kitchen. Scarcity does a lot of heavy lifting for Beaches & Cream’s reputation, and once you accept that, the food itself becomes a lot easier to judge fairly. Add in the nostalgia of the 1950s soda fountain theming, the working jukebox, and decades of guests building the Kitchen Sink into a bucket list item, and you have a restaurant that thrives on atmosphere and thrill first, and calories second.
One more thing worth knowing before you book: not everything here requires a reservation. Beaches & Cream also operates an outdoor walk-up window along the Beach Club Resort pool path, serving many of the same sandwiches, sides, and ice cream items as the sit-down menu without needing an advance dining reservation. If you cannot get a table, the walk-up window is a legitimate way to still get your ice cream fix.
Beaches and Cream Review: The Savory Menu, Item by Item

The savory side of the Beaches & Cream menu reads like a classic American soda fountain lineup: burgers, deli sandwiches, and one very good grilled cheese. We went through the full lineup for this review, and the pattern held across almost every dish. Everything is competently made, nothing is bad, and almost nothing would make a top ten list of Walt Disney World entrees. Here is how each one breaks down. Guests should be aware that Walt Disney World’s yearly food and beverage price increase in October hit some savory entrees hard, with 10% price increases.
Angus Beef Burger, $25.00.

The Angus Beef Burger comes topped with cheddar, lettuce, and tomato on a freshly baked bun, served with a choice of potato tots, french fries, or fresh fruit, according to the current dinner menu on Disney’s own site. On paper, that is about as straightforward as a burger description gets, and on the plate, it delivers exactly what the description promises. Nothing more. The patty itself is cooked competently, and the bun holds together the way a freshly baked bun should. Cheddar, lettuce, and tomato are all present and accounted for, and the tots or fries on the side do their job without complaint. We suggest the tots. During our most recent visit, the tots were very good and our burger came with a generous portion.

If you set this burger down next to a diner burger almost anywhere off property, or honestly next to several counter-service memorable burgers elsewhere at Walt Disney World, it would not stand out. It is a fine burger. It is not a memorable one, and at $25.00 for a fairly basic build with no specialty sauce, no upgraded cheese, and no signature twist, it is priced more like a statement piece than a diner classic. When guests can go to places like Chef Art Smith’s Homecomin’ at Disney Springs, Wailulu Bar at Disney’s Polynesian Resort, and Steakhouse 71 at Disney’s Contemporary Resort for a far better burger for the same money or less, this burger is not why you visit Beaches & Cream.
French Dip Sandwich, $23.00

The French Dip Sandwich is a toasted French roll piled with thinly sliced roast beef and Swiss, topped with crispy fried onions, and served with au jus on the side and a choice of potato tots, french fries, or fresh fruit. This is one of the more solid options on the savory menu. The roast beef is sliced thin enough to stay tender, the crispy onions add a texture the burgers on this menu could honestly use more of, and the au jus does what au jus is supposed to do. It will not make you forget a great deli French Dip, but among the Beaches & Cream sandwiches, it is a quietly good pick. Well… a good pick as long as you can ignore the price point being a few dollars too high, even with a Walt Disney World annual passholder discount.

Impossible Burger, $23.00

The Impossible Burger swaps in a plant-based patty, plant-based mayonnaise, and a seasonal vegetable relish on a house-baked multigrain bun, with the same choice of potato tots, French fries, or fresh fruit on the side. This is a solid plant-based option, and the multigrain bun and vegetable relish give it a bit more personality than the standard Angus Burger gets. It is a reasonable choice if a plant-based burger is what you are after. Sadly, the two times we have ordered this, we have wished we were having a plant-based burger at other restaurants that make one better than this. It is fine, but just fine.

Cheddar-Bacon-Ranch Chicken Sandwich, $21.00

The Cheddar-Bacon-Ranch Chicken Sandwich comes with sautéed onion, lettuce, and tomato on a multigrain bun, again served with a choice of potato tots, French fries, or fresh fruit. This is a fine, unremarkable chicken sandwich that leans on a familiar cheddar-bacon-ranch combination you have almost certainly had somewhere else. It does the job as a lighter savory option, but it does nothing the name doesn’t already promise.
Beaches & Cream Grilled Cheese, $18.00

The Beaches & Cream Grilled Cheese comes with creamy tomato soup, with bacon or ham available to add for $5.00 each, and the soup can be swapped for potato tots, french fries, or fresh fruit. We do not recommend the upgrade. The bacon and ham are not worth paying more! We did during this visit and would not do that again!

At $18.00, this is the most approachable price point on the savory menu, and it is also one of the better dishes here. A simple, well made grilled cheese and tomato soup combination is hard to mess up, and Beaches & Cream does not mess it up. If you are looking for the most kid friendly and comfort food forward option on the menu, this is it.
Reuben Sandwich, $22.00

The Reuben Sandwich brings corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss, and Thousand Island dressing on marbled rye bread, served with a choice of potato tots, fries, or fresh fruit. This is a classic deli build, and Beaches & Cream executes it about as well as you would hope. The corned beef has good flavor, the sauerkraut is not overdone, and the rye bread holds up under the dressing. It will not compete with a dedicated deli’s Reuben, but for a theme park resort restaurant, it is a solid, satisfying option.

Patty Melt, $23.00

The Patty Melt is built with Swiss cheese, sauteed onions, and a garlic peppercorn dressing on marbled rye bread. Of all the savory items on the menu, this is the one with the most going on flavor wise. The garlic peppercorn dressing gives it a sharper edge than the Angus Burger’s fairly plain build, and the sauteed onions add some sweetness to balance it out. If you are choosing between the Angus Burger and the Patty Melt, the Patty Melt is the more interesting sandwich, even if it is still solidly in average theme park entree territory rather than must order territory.
Taken together, the savory menu at Beaches & Cream is consistent. Nothing on it is bad, a few items like the French Dip, the Grilled Cheese, and the Patty Melt are genuinely solid, and nothing here is worth fighting for a hard to get reservation on its own merits. That is an important distinction. This is a perfectly fine place to eat lunch or dinner. It is not a destination for the food.
Beaches and Cream Review: The Rest of the Menu Follows the Same Pattern
We have run into this exact dynamic before at a different resort area icon. Our recent Toothsome Chocolate Emporium review found a similar split, entrees that were fine at best, alongside desserts that clearly got more attention from the kitchen than the savory menu did. Beaches & Cream tells a version of the same story. The sandwiches and entrees here are competent, average theme park resort fare, while the ice cream program is where the restaurant actually earns its reputation.
Beaches and Cream Review: Better Burgers Are Not Hard to Find at Walt Disney World

Here is the part we will say plainly: if a great burger is the goal, Beaches & Cream is not the move. Walt Disney World has several burgers that outclass the Angus Beef Burger without much argument, and a few of them sit at the exact same $23.00 price point. The seasonal Beef Wellington Burger at D-Luxe Burger in Disney Springs does more with two pressed patties, crispy prosciutto, mushroom duxelles, Gruyere, and an herbed puff pastry bun than the Angus Burger does with cheddar, lettuce, and tomato, and it runs $8.01 cheaper.

Photo by Jon Self
Over at Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort, the Wayfinder Burger at Wailulu Bar & Grill also costs $23.00, and in our full review of that restaurant, we had a hard time thinking of a burger on property that beats it. Two pressed patties, American cheese, onion jam, and a punchy volcano sauce do a lot more for the price than cheddar, lettuce, and tomato.

If you are willing to eat a burger before noon, the Steakhouse 71 Breakfast Burger at Disney’s Contemporary Resort runs the same $23.00 and piles two patties with pork belly, avocado, a fried egg, and a hash brown patty into what our review called one of the most memorable breakfasts on property. Steakhouse 71’s lunchtime Stack Burger is also regularly cited as one of the best burgers at Walt Disney World. None of these require you to fight for a hard to get reservation at a restaurant that seats a fraction of what most Walt Disney World table service spots can hold.
Beaches and Cream Review: Where Beaches & Cream Actually Wins, The Ice Cream

If the savory menu is the reason people struggle to get excited about Beaches & Cream, the ice cream menu is the reason the reservation books stay full anyway. This is where the kitchen clearly puts its focus, and it shows.
Kitchen Sink, $39.00 (Serves Four)

The Kitchen Sink is the entire reason most people book this restaurant in the first place. Scoops of vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cookies and cream, and mint chocolate chip ice cream are topped with hot fudge, peanut butter, SNICKERS pieces, a fresh baked brownie, and smothered in every other topping the kitchen has on hand. It is also available in Chocolate Lovers or Neapolitan versions. At $39.00 to feed a table of four, this is genuinely one of the better value desserts at Walt Disney World on a per person basis, and it is built for the spectacle as much as the flavor. Cast members ring a bell when one goes out, the table around you turns to look, and for a few minutes the entire dining room is focused on one absurd bucket of ice cream. This is the dish Beaches & Cream is famous for, and it earns that fame.
SNICKERS Sundae, $13.50

The SNICKERS Sundae takes three scoops of vanilla ice cream and smothers them in hot fudge, marshmallow topping, and SNICKERS bar pieces, then finishes with whipped cream, chopped peanuts, and a cherry. This is a smart option if the Kitchen Sink feels like too much commitment. It hits the same hot fudge and candy bar notes in a size built for one or two people to share, and the marshmallow topping gives it a slightly different profile than a standard hot fudge sundae. Of everything on the ice cream menu, this is the easiest recommendation for a smaller appetite.
Fudge Brownie Mudslide, $15.00

The Fudge Brownie Mudslide is what happens when Beaches and Cream decides one dessert should do the work of three. It starts with a brownie at the bottom of the glass, smothered in hot fudge before anything else even arrives. Then come three scoops of vanilla ice cream, which act as the cool, creamy counterweight to all that chocolate. For the record, during our most recent visit, the brownie was the weakest part of this sweet treat.
From there, the sundae gets its personality. Chocolate sandwich cookies are tucked in for crunch (and on our visit, two were perched on top as Mickey ears, which is about as Disney as a dessert can get). A tall cloud of whipped cream follows, drizzled with chocolate syrup that runs down the sides of the glass, and the whole thing is crowned with a bright red cherry.
At $15.00, it’s one of the pricier single sundaes on the menu, but it’s also big enough to share between two people, especially after a burger and tots. If you love brownie sundaes, this is the move. If you’re lukewarm on chocolate, the Classic Banana Split or an Old-Fashioned Sundae might suit you better. Either way, bring a spoon for everyone at the table. You’ll need it.
Cookie Fries with Dipping Sauce, $8.50 (A Plant-Based For Our Beaches and Cream Review)

Cookie Fries with assorted dips round out the dessert menu, and they are plant based, which makes them one of the more flexible options here for guests avoiding dairy or eggs. Warm, fry shaped cookies paired with dipping sauces are a fun, shareable format, and they are a solid lower commitment choice if you want a Beaches & Cream dessert without going all in on a full sundae.
The through line across the ice cream menu is simple. This kitchen knows exactly what it is good at, and it leans into it. The Kitchen Sink in particular is built to be an event, not just a dessert, and it is the single best reason to actually book this restaurant.
Beaches and Cream Review: So Why Do We Still Go?

You mean besides friends wanting to visit this hard-to-get restaurant? Well, Beaches & Cream is more than its food, and we are completely fine with that. This is a restaurant that has coasted on nostalgia, atmosphere, and scarcity for decades, and it works. The 1950s soda fountain theming, the jukebox, the classic sundaes, and above all the towering Kitchen Sink are the actual draw. We would not book a hard to get reservation here chasing the Angus Burger, the French Dip, or the Patty Melt, solid as some of them are. We would absolutely book one chasing a sundae, and if the sit-down reservation is not available, the outdoor walk-up window is worth remembering as a lower-pressure backup for the same ice cream.
Beaches and Cream Review: Quick Tips

- Book the reservation for the ice cream, not the entrees. Expectations set this way will serve you well.
- The Angus Beef Burger ($25.00) is fine but unremarkable. If a great burger is the priority, D-Luxe Burger, Wailulu Bar & Grill, or Steakhouse 71 will serve you better, often at the same price.
- The French Dip ($22.00), Grilled Cheese ($18.00), and Patty Melt ($23.00) are the strongest savory picks if you want food with a bit more character.
- The Kitchen Sink ($39.00, serves four) is the single best reason to book this restaurant. Split it among a full table.
- No reservation? Try the outdoor walk-up window along the pool path, which serves many of the same sandwiches, sides, and ice cream items.
- Reservations here are hard to get for a reason. Book as early in the 60-day window as you can. You could also wait until 24 hours before and try to grab a spot left open by a canceled reservation.
- Pair the visit with a walk down Disney’s BoardWalk for more fall snacking before or after your meal.
Beaches and Cream Review: Worth Your Time (For the Right Reasons)

Beaches & Cream earns its spot on a Walt Disney World itinerary, just not for the reason its hardest-to-get reservation might suggest. Go for the tiny, nostalgic dining room, go for the jukebox, and go for the ice cream. The savory menu will not let you down exactly, several items like the French Dip and the Grilled Cheese are genuinely solid, but do not go in expecting the Angus Beef Burger, or really anything else savory on the menu, to be the best burger you eat on your trip. Set expectations around atmosphere, nostalgia, and a table-sized bucket of ice cream, and this remains one of the more charming stops at Walt Disney World.
For more theme park dining reviews, visit MSM News every weekday at noon Eastern Time. Additionally, we sometimes post bonus theme park dining reviews. As always, eat like you mean it!

Expertise. Ease. Value.
Ready for your bucket list trip? Our trusted partner, MEI-Travel, will handle the planning so you can focus on the memories. They offer free vacation planning services and have nearly 20 years of experience creating memorable vacations.
Contact for a fee-free, no-obligation quote today.