The Cookie That Stole Christmas is Crumbl’s Grinch-inspired holiday cookie for December 15–20, anchoring a festive weekly lineup that includes Eggnog Tres Leches Cake, a new Red Velvet Cookie Sandwich, and other seasonal favorites that feel straight out of a theme park holiday event.
What is Crumbl?
Crumbl is a rapidly growing American franchise bakery specializing in large, gourmet cookies, famous for its distinct pink box packaging. Founded in 2017 by cousins Jason McGowan and Sawyer Hemsley in Logan, Utah, the company has expanded quickly, fueled in large part by its viral presence on social media platforms like TikTok and Instagram.
The key to Crumbl’s appeal is its weekly rotating menu. While its classic Milk Chocolate Chip cookie is always available, the other five specialty flavors change every Monday, drawing from a library of over 200 unique recipes. This flavor rotation creates anticipation and encourages repeat visits. The cookies are baked in an open-concept kitchen and are often served warm, with a focus on fun, indulgent, and visually appealing desserts. There are two Crumbl locations in the Orlando metro area and many nationwide.
What Is The Cookie That Stole Christmas?
The Cookie That Stole Christmas is a bright green sugar cookie topped with a tiny red frosting heart, simple, bold, and instantly recognizable. While the name stops short of officially referencing the Dr. Seuss character, the inspiration is unmistakable. It’s festive, mischievous, and designed to spark immediate holiday recognition the moment it appears in the box.
Visually, the cookie feels like it could sit comfortably next to exclusive holiday treats at Grinchmas at Universal Orlando Resort. In fact, it is very similar to cookies sold during the holiday season at Universal Islands of Adventure. The vivid green coloring does the heavy lifting, while the red heart adds just enough storytelling to evoke the familiar holiday redemption arc fans know so well.
Cookie That Stole Christmas: Why This Cookie Is Getting Theme Park–Level Buzz
Limited availability is the secret ingredient. Like a party-exclusive cupcake or festival-only dessert, The Cookie That Stole Christmas is only around for a short time. That scarcity drives the same behavior theme park fans know all too well: opening-day visits, social media reviews, box reveals, and side-by-side comparisons to past holiday offerings. Crumbl’s weekly menu drops have become appointment viewing, much like food booth menus debuting for Epcot festivals or holiday parties.
Taste and Texture: Simple, Sweet, and Nostalgic
At its core, The Cookie That Stole Christmas is a classic sugar cookie. The texture leans soft and tender, with a cake-like crumb that works well for a frosting-forward design. The sweetness is straightforward and familiar, making it less experimental than some of Crumbl’s more elaborate offerings, but that simplicity is part of the appeal. Much like many theme park holiday snacks, this cookie prioritizes nostalgia over complexity. It’s not trying to reinvent dessert; it’s trying to taste as Christmas feels.
The Full Crumbl Lineup: December 15–20
While The Cookie That Stole Christmas may be the star, the rest of the weekly lineup reads like a holiday dessert buffet:
Eggnog Tres Leches Cake delivers a seasonal twist on a classic, featuring light vanilla cake soaked in a tres leches eggnog sauce, topped with whipped cream and finished with a dusting of cinnamon.
NEW Red Velvet Cookie Sandwich features two red velvet cookies filled with vanilla cream cheese frosting and white chocolate ganache, complete with a star-shaped cutout for extra holiday flair.
Peanut Butter Cup ft. Reese’s offers comfort-food familiarity with a peanut butter cookie base, melted peanut butter chips, and chopped Reese’s cups.
Chocolate Crumb (ft. OREO®) brings back a fan favorite, combining a rich chocolate cookie packed with OREO® pieces, topped with vanilla cream cheese frosting and even more cookie crumble.
Candy Cane Brownie rounds out the lineup with a rich chocolate base topped with peppermint buttercream, chocolate ganache, and crunchy candy cane pieces—arguably the most overtly Christmas-flavored cookie of the week.
Why Theme Park Fans Should Care
For theme park food fans, this Crumbl lineup scratches the same seasonal itch as holiday snacks inside the parks, without needing a ticket, reservation, or mobile order window. The Cookie That Stole Christmas, in particular, feels like the kind of limited-time dessert that would typically debut alongside a holiday overlay or exclusive event.
It’s festive, unapologetically seasonal, and designed to disappear just as quickly as it arrives. In that way, it captures the very thing theme park holiday food does best: creating a fleeting moment of Christmas magic you can literally taste.
The Cookie That Stole Christmas
The Cookie That Stole Christmas may be simple in design, but it succeeds because it understands the assignment. It’s nostalgic, instantly recognizable, and part of a broader holiday lineup that feels carefully curated for the season.
For the week of December 15–20, Crumbl’s menu feels less like a bakery rotation and more like a holiday event, one that wouldn’t feel out of place alongside the seasonal food offerings at your favorite theme park. Whether you’re chasing holiday vibes or just looking for something green, sweet, and fleeting, this is one cookie worth stealing time for.
For more theme park-related news and information, visit MSM News. As always, eat like you mean it!
Expertise. Ease. Value.
Ready for your bucket list trip? Our trusted partner, MEI-Travel, will handle the planning so you can focus on the memories. They offer free vacation planning services and have nearly 20 years of experience creating memorable vacations.
Contact for a fee-free, no-obligation quote today.
