Today, we have a Busch Gardens Tampa Bay Christmas Town cheesecake review for you. Additionally, we hope it makes you smile a little this holiday season.

This Christmas Town season, we have the tale of two cheesecakes. These can be found at the Evergreen Eats Cabin during the event that runs nightly through January 5, 2026.

A Tale of Two Cheeses: Evergreen Eats’ Christmas Town Cheesecake Review

Gather ’round, weary travelers of Christmas Town, and listen to the tale of the two magnificent, albeit slightly overpriced, cheesecakes lurking within the mystical confines of Evergreen Eats (Cabin #3). This is not merely a food cabin, my friends; it is a culinary nexus where the Holiday Yule Log and Christmas Eggnog Bread Pudding also beckon. At a stately $9.99 a slice (before discounts, because this is an event, not a bargain bin), these aren’t just desserts—they’re a commitment. Still, were they worth the metaphorical mortgage payment? Let’s dive into the delicious drama.

The Contender: Apple Spiced Cheesecake

The menu whispers to you: “Spiced apple crumble with cinnamon cream cheese.”

Ah, the Apple Spiced Cheesecake. It arrives, a brave, festive soldier of dairy, utterly convinced it’s the star of your holiday plate. The very description, “Spiced apple crumble,” sounds less like a topping and more like a heroic epic poem of autumnal flavor, meticulously crumbled by tiny, festive elves. However, the foundation? “Cinnamon cream cheese.” Not just plain cream cheese, oh no. This is cream cheese that has undergone a rigorous training montage, infused with the very essence of holiday spice, reaching a state of creamy, cinnamon-dusted enlightenment.

This cheesecake is the culinary equivalent of your favorite, chunky holiday sweater: comforting, robust, and utterly essential for a December afternoon, even in Florida’s tepid winter air. It’s an aggressive warmth, the kind that makes you want to immediately buy a cozy blanket and argue over who gets to hold the remote. An acceptable option, indeed, and a glorious, crumbling ode to the season. Okay, we may be overselling it in this Christmas Town cheesecake review. Still, our group thought this made a solid dessert option.

The Champion: Pumpkin Cheesecake

The menu promises: “Creamy cheesecake, cinnamon dusted with whipped cream.”

Now, our Christmas Town cheesecake review takes us to the Pumpkin Cheesecake, the smooth, velvety, unapologetic monarch of the dessert world. While its menu description might seem less verbose, it lacks a grand “crumble” like its rival. Still, do not be fooled. It boasts “Creamy cheesecake,” a phrase so confident, so simple, it implies a texture so flawless it could be used to resurface a roller coaster track. In fairness, our slice of Pumpkin Cheesecake did not offer great presentation, but it did present solid holiday flavors.

The “cinnamon dusted” detail suggests that a benevolent Christmas deity descended from the heavens, sprinkled a handful of cinnamon magic, and declared, “Let there be flavor!” However, let us not forget the final flourish: “whipped cream.” Not just a dollop, but a cloud, a peak, a Mount Olympus of ethereal lightness, providing a necessary, snow-white counterpoint to the rich, earthy pumpkin. This dessert is elegance and indulgence perfectly balanced. It knows it’s good, and it doesn’t need a complicated backstory to prove it.

The Sampler Lanyard: Or, How to Commit to Dessert like a Pro

Now, for the true Christmas miracle: the Sampler Lanyard. Without this crucial accessory, you are merely a peasant, forking over $9.99 a slice for an à la carte experience that, while delicious, carries the distinct sting of a theme park transaction.

The Sampler Lanyard is essentially a pre-purchased punch card for designated festive food and beverage items across Christmas Town. It transforms those pricey individual items into a deeply satisfying, bulk-discounted culinary journey.

• The Math Magic: If you commit to the 10-item lanyard, and especially if you’re a Pass Member who receives two glorious bonus samples (12 total for the price of 10!), your effective per-sample price plummets to $6.50 or less.
• The Strategy: Suddenly, that $9.99 cheesecake is a $6.50 victory. You’re not just buying dessert; you’re winning at the event economy. It’s the difference between a spontaneous, regretted splurge and a well-planned, guilt-free feast. The Lanyard is less a necklace and more a certified License to Indulge.

Christmas Town Cheesecake Review

Both cheesecakes are solid holiday fare from Evergreen Eats (Cabin #3). Still, to truly appreciate their quality without weeping over your bank statement, you must wield the power of the Sampler Lanyard. Go forth and crumble, you magnificent, cinnamon-dusted dessert champions!

For more theme park dining reviews, visit MSM News every weekday at noon Eastern Time. Additionally, we sometimes publish bonus theme park dining reviews, such as this Christmas Town cheesecake review. As always, eat like you mean it!

Expertise. Ease. Value.

Ready for your bucket list trip? Our trusted partner, MEI-Travel, will handle the planning so you can focus on the memories. They offer free vacation planning services and have nearly 20 years of experience creating memorable vacations. 

Contact for a fee-free, no-obligation quote today.