Bread Box CityWalk Orlando Review: Worth the Price?
Bread Box CityWalk Orlando serves solid sandwiches like the Turkey Pastrami and Italian, but we break down whether the price tag holds up.
Photo by Jon Self
Bread Box CityWalk Orlando has been the closest thing Universal’s entertainment district has to a proper deli since it opened on the second level back in July 2014. On a recent visit, we ordered two of the menu’s more straightforward options, the Turkey Pastrami and the Italian, to see how the sandwiches themselves hold up and whether the price tag still makes sense in 2026.
A Quick Look at Bread Box CityWalk Orlando
Photo Credit: Universal Orlando Resort
The concept has stayed consistent since day one: made-to-order sandwiches, melts, soups, and shakes served inside a bright, diner-inspired space decorated with a wall of multicolored lunchboxes and booth benches that hang from the ceiling on chains. One thing worth knowing before you go: this is not the same $7.95 sandwich shop it was at opening. Bread Box launched in 2014 with every sandwich priced at a flat $7.95. More than a decade later, the current menu puts most sandwiches in the $15.99 to $17.99 range. That is a substantial jump, even accounting for over ten years of general price increases across theme park dining. That detail sets up exactly the value question we kept coming back to during our visit.
Turkey Pastrami
The Turkey Pastrami comes built with white cheddar, tomato, bacon, Dijonnaise, and grilled onions on light rye, currently priced at $16.99 with a side of chips or tater tots. The rye bread does real work here. It holds up under the sandwich’s weight without turning soggy and adds just enough of its own flavor to keep the whole thing from tasting one note. Overall, this is a solid sandwich, well balanced between the sharpness of the cheddar, the sweetness of the grilled onions, and the tang from the Dijonnaise.
Our side of tater tots on this visit was noticeably small for the price of the sandwich, which fed directly into our bigger concern with the meal. Nearly $17 for a sandwich and a modest scoop of tots feels steep compared to what a similar deli style sandwich would cost just about anywhere outside Universal CityWalk.
This is not just our opinion. Independent theme park dining trackers have graded Bread Box’s value at a C minus, specifically citing how little food guests get for the price compared to nearby competition. Our tots portion this visit lines up with that criticism.
What About the Italian Sandwich at Bread Box CityWalk Orlando?
The Italian sandwich stacks ham, calabrese salami, big eye pepperoni, and provolone with lettuce, tomato, red onion, pepperoncini, herbed oil and vinegar, and Duke’s mayo on a house baked roll, priced at $16.99. The components here are genuinely good. The meat selection is varied without feeling like overkill, the pepperoncini adds real brightness, and the herbed oil and vinegar hits the classic deli Italian sub notes guests expect.
The one element that stands out is the Duke’s mayo. Classic Italian sub tradition generally leans on oil and vinegar alone. Sure, plenty of purists would argue mayonnaise has no business anywhere near an Italian sandwich. Our best guess for why Bread Box includes it anyway comes down to where the restaurant is actually located. Duke’s is a Southern pantry staple, and folding it into an Italian sub reads less like a break from tradition and more like Bread Box quietly building a Southern deli identity on top of a classic format, the same instinct that shows up in its BLT and its Dijonnaise-forward Turkey Pastrami.
It is a small deviation, but it does not hurt the sandwich. If anything, it adds a bit of creaminess that ties the sharper, more acidic ingredients together.
Is Bread Box Worth It?
Both sandwiches we tried were genuinely good. The rye on the Turkey Pastrami holds together well, and the Italian’s ingredient list is well thought out even with its unconventional mayo addition. The issue isn’t quality; it is value. At nearly $17 (before any discounts) a sandwich with only a modest side included, Bread Box asks guests to pay a meaningful premium compared to what a similar sandwich costs at a deli or sandwich shop outside the resort. That gap has only grown since the shop’s $7.95 debut in 2014.
If you are already planning to eat at CityWalk and want something more substantial than a quick snack, Bread Box remains a solid choice. Just go in aware that you are paying theme park district prices for a very good, but not extraordinary, deli sandwich. However, with new additions like Joey Fatone’s Fat One’s and Five Guys crashing the Universal CityWalk Orlando party, Bread Box no longer offers the value it used to.
For more theme park dining reviews, visit MSM News every weekday at noon Eastern Time. Additionally, we sometimes post bonus theme park dining reviews. As always, eat like you mean it!
Expertise. Ease. Value.
Ready for your bucket list trip? Our trusted partner, MEI-Travel, will handle the planning so you can focus on the memories. They offer free vacation planning services and have nearly 20 years of experience creating memorable vacations.
Contact for a fee-free, no-obligation quote today.
