Review: Cold Stone Creamery’s 2026 Holiday Creations Bring Brownies, Peppermint and a Whole Lot of Sugar

Salted Caramel Brookie or Peppermint Chocolate Swirl? Our food reporters tried both new Cold Stone holiday Creations available through January 5, 2027, including at Universal CityWalk Orlando.

Photo by Jon Self
Cold Stone Creamery has officially swapped its fall Cozy Collection for the holidays, and that means two new Creations and the annual reminder that nobody has ever needed a waffle bowl less than in December (and nobody has ever turned one down either). We covered the full Cold Stone holiday flavor lineup when it was announced, and now our food reporters have taken the two new Creations for a spin.
The holiday menu is available now at Cold Stone locations nationwide, including Universal CityWalk Orlando, through January 5, 2027. So here is the big question: is either one worth your theme park dessert budget, or should you save your stomach space for something else on the walk back to the parking garage?
What’s New on the Cold Stone Holiday Menu

This year’s holiday lineup centers on two new ice cream flavors, each featured in the signature Cold Stone holiday Creations:
- Salted Caramel Brookie: Salted Caramel Brownie Ice Cream with Cookie Dough, Brownie and Caramel
- Peppermint Chocolate Swirl: White Chocolate & Ganache Ice Cream with Holiday OREO Cookies, White Chips and Crushed Peppermint
Prices vary by location. For our visit, the prices looked like this:
- Like It Size $7.49
- Love it Size $8.49
- Gotta Have It Size $8.99
“Holiday desserts should be just as memorable as the celebrations themselves,” said Courtney Maxedon, VP of Marketing and Digital Strategy at Kahala Brands , parent company of Cold Stone Creamery. “Whether our guests are enjoying our new Creations™ or bringing one of our cakes to a holiday gathering, we’re excited to be part of the memories they make this season.”
Salted Caramel Brookie Review

Our first attempt at eating one of the Cold Stone holiday Creations took us to the Salted Caramel Brookie. It is the heavyweight of the two, and you can tell before the first bite because the entire cup is roughly one shade of brown. If a holiday dessert is supposed to look festive, this one missed the memo. If it is supposed to taste like a bakery case fell into your ice cream, it nailed it.
The ice cream: The Salted Caramel Brownie Ice Cream is the nice part of this Creation and honestly the best new thing on the holiday menu. It has a rich, buttery caramel flavor up front, followed by a cocoa note that tastes more like brownie batter than straight chocolate. The salt is noticeable without being aggressive, and it does a lot of work keeping the first half of the cup from tipping into toothache territory. However, we felt the caramel can be overwhelmed by the other components as you eat it.
The mix-ins: The brownie pieces were fudgy rather than dry, which is not always a given with ice cream mix-ins. The cookie dough held up surprisingly well after being smashed and folded on the cold stone, staying soft with a little bit of chew. Every few bites, you get a spoonful that hits brownie, cookie dough, and caramel all at once, and that is when the name makes the most sense. It truly is a brookie in ice cream form. Nonetheless, the brownie pieces sink to the bottom and were larger than expected in our order. Still, the brownie provided good flavor, especially the more you had of it.
Good, But Heavy

The caramel: As mentioned earlier, we felt this needed a more robust caramel flavor. While it was in some bites, in others, it was absent. If we had just ordered the ice cream and not the Creation, this may have gone differently.
Who should order it: Chocolate and caramel fans, anyone who orders brownie sundaes on purpose, and people who think peppermint belongs in toothpaste. We would strongly recommend the smallest size or a shared cup. A Gotta Have It portion of this would require a nap, and most Cold Stone locations do not offer nap pods (yet).
Verdict: Good, but rich. Great ice cream base, but a bit too little caramel flavor. Best shared.
Peppermint Chocolate Swirl Review

The other version of the Cold Stone holiday Creations presents a different flavor profile. If the Brookie is a heavy holiday dinner, the Peppermint Chocolate Swirl is the after-dinner mint. It also looks the part, with flecks of red-and-white peppermint and dark cookie pieces running through a pale base. Well, it should have looked the part. Our Creation was so well mixed that the holiday appearance was lost. Still, of the two Cold Stone Holiday Creations, this one actually looks like it belongs on a holiday menu.
The ice cream: The White Chocolate & Ganache Ice Cream is creamy and smooth with a sweet, vanilla-forward white chocolate flavor. The ganache ribbons are the secret weapon here. They add a darker chocolate note that keeps the white chocolate from becoming too one-dimensional, and they give the cup a little visual swirl that lives up to the name.
The peppermint: The crushed peppermint is what should shine with this Creation. It adds a cool, bright flavor that cuts through the richness, plus a crunch that the rest of the cup needs. It is noticeable without tasting like a candy cane exploded, and the pieces soften slightly as the ice cream melts, so later bites are little more minty and less crunchy. If you love peppermint, ask for a little extra. In fact, we found too little peppermint flavor in the bites we had of this.
Holiday OREO Cookies

The mix-ins: The Holiday OREO cookies soften as they are mixed in, giving the whole cup a mild cookies-and-cream feel that pairs nicely with the mint. The white chips were the weakest part. They added sweetness more than flavor and had a slightly waxy texture once they cooled, and we wouldn’t miss them if we left them out.
Who should order it: Peppermint fans, cookies and cream fans, and anyone who wants something that tastes like the holidays without feeling like a full meal. It is also the more refreshing option on a warm Florida December night (which, let’s be honest, is most of them).
Verdict: We enjoyed it and it is clearly more holiday season than the other one. Balanced, festive, and easy to finish.
Salted Caramel Brookie vs. Peppermint Chocolate Swirl

These two Cold Stone holiday Creations are built for completely different moods. The Salted Caramel Brookie is the indulgent one, with the better ice cream base but too many sweet layers stacked on top of it. The Peppermint Chocolate Swirl is the more balanced one, with the components doing a good job of keeping each bite interesting from start to finish.
- Best ice cream base: Salted Caramel Brownie
- Best mix-ins: Peppermint Chocolate Swirl, thanks to the peppermint crunch and cookies
- Sweetest: Salted Caramel Brookie, by a wide margin
- Most festive: Peppermint Chocolate Swirl
- Easiest to finish: Peppermint Chocolate Swirl
If you can only try one, go with the Peppermint Chocolate Swirl. If you are splitting with a friend, get one of each and trade halfway through. We did! That might be the best way to enjoy either Creation.
Tips for ordering the Cold Stone Holiday Creations
- Go with the smallest size if you plan to try both. These are rich, and a Like It or Love It size is plenty.
- Try the Salted Caramel Brownie Ice Cream on its own if you want the best part of the Brookie without the sugar overload.
- A waffle bowl adds crunch, but it also adds even more sweetness, especially with the Brookie. Of course, the waffle bowl will add to the price as well.
Cold Stone Holiday Gift Card Bonus
Cold Stone is again offering a $15 bonus eCard with every $50 in online gift card purchases through December 31, 2026, at ColdStoneCreamery.com.
What to know before you visit Cold Stone at Universal CityWalk Orlando

- Location: Universal CityWalk Orlando, no theme park admission required. This is found near guest services and Starbucks.
- Hours: 11:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m, most days, with slightly later hours on Friday and Saturday.
- Availability: Holiday Creations through January 5, 2027
- Discounts: Universal Annual Pass discounts apply
Cold Stone Holiday Creations: Worth a Stop?

Cold Stone did not reinvent the holiday dessert here, but it did not need to. The Peppermint Chocolate Swirl is the one we would go back for, thanks to the the mix-ins keeping things balanced. The Salted Caramel Brookie is a solid choice for serious chocolate and caramel fans, as long as you go in knowing it is a sugar commitment. Either way, it is an easy holiday treat to grab on a Universal CityWalk Orlando night out or wherever you are having fun.

Looking for more holiday treats? Check out our Gideon’s Hallowed Trinity at Hot Cookie Hour coverage, the Tiff’s Treats Blue Chocolate Chip Cookies for Percy Jackson, the new McDonald’s Home Alone Meal and our Beaches & Cream review at Disney’s Beach Club, home of one of the most famous ice cream counters in Orlando.
For more theme park dining reviews, visit MSM News every weekday at noon Eastern Time. Additionally, we sometimes post bonus theme park dining reviews. As always, eat like you mean it!

Expertise. Ease. Value.
Ready for your bucket list trip? Our trusted partner, MEI-Travel, will handle the planning so you can focus on the memories. They offer free vacation planning services and have nearly 20 years of experience creating memorable vacations.
Contact for a fee-free, no-obligation quote today.